Apple wins slide-to-unlock case against Motorola

Injunction unlikely to be enforcedMobile phones News By Chris Smith Thursday at 20:55 UTC | Tell us what you think [ 3 comments ]

Tweet Slide-to-unlock is becoming a key feature of the patent wars

A German court has found that Motorola has infringed on Apple's patented slide-to-unlock technology with its Android smartphones.

The court victory, which is being touted as "a big win for Apple over Android," means Cupertino, in theory, has an injunction on Motorola smartphone sales in Germany.

The case relates to patent EP1964022, which covers the act of unlocking a touchscreen display by swiping your finger from one area of the screen to another.

Apple owns the patent, which it has used on iOS devices since the first iPhone.

New design already implemented

However, Motorola plans to appeal the verdict and says that it has already has an alternative phone unlock method in place, so expects no ban to ever come into effect.

A Moto spokeswoman said: "Today's ruling in the patent litigation brought by Apple in Munich, Germany, concerns a software feature related to phone unlocking in select Motorola devices sold in Germany.

"Motorola has implemented a new design for the feature. Therefore, we expect no impact on current supply or future sales."

Yet more lawsuits

However, with the appeals and counter appeals set to rumble on, the Munich victory will probably open the door for Apple to challenge more manufacturers carrying the Android operating system and using slide-to-unlock.

Motorola may also become the chief target of Apple's legal wrath once it is officially acquired by Google.

Patent expert Florien Mueller told the BBC: "[This is a] very significant win for Apple against Android.

"After Google closes the acquisition of Motorola Mobility, the Apple-Motorola Mobility dispute will soon gain importance transcending that of the global battle with Samsung," he added.

Via: BBC News

Tags: Apple, Motorola, iPhone, iPad, slide-to-unlock, AndroidTweetreddit!Stumbleupon  Your comments (3) Click to add a new commentweedymuff

Saturday at 02:32 UTC

3. Apple must be lining the courts in germany with lots of pocket money as they seem to get away with anything there!

Alert a moderator

unlixes

Friday at 13:08 UTC

2. Yeah, this is one of the most nauseating patents. Especially since the Motorola one was, apparently, sliding an icon out of a circle, rather than following a set path. I don't understand how these patents are allowed to stand, let alone be upheld like this.

Luckily, they're easy enough to get around so, again, I think the idea that this means Android is in a noose is overstated.

Alert a moderator

sirspoon

Thursday at 23:43 UTC

1. can someone explain why they are allowed to patent something that firstly already existed before hand, and secondly, is blindingly obvious (basically use an interface to issue a command to a gadget) I just don't get it.

Alert a moderator

Tell us what you thinkYou need to Log in or register to post comments

By submitting this form you agree to our Terms of Use and so are legally responsible for anything you submit. DO NOT submit anything which may violate the Terms of Use or another person's rights including copyrighted or offensive materials.

Submit Explore News Mobile phonesVoIPOther phones Related News iPad 3 leaks expose Retina Display, 8-megapixel camera?Apple App Store about to hit 25 billion downloadsHow to install Android on other devicesApple this week: more blame than biscuitsiPad tablet market share down to 57 per cent Apple in 2012: 10 Things to expect

iPad 3, iPhone 5, iLife '12, iWork '12, death of the iPod Classic

Phones@TechRadar

Our guide to the best new mobile phones:

LatestGalaxy S3Galaxy NexusOrange San Francisco 2HTC TitanMoto RazrHTC RadarCurve 9360HTC ExplorerWave 3Sensation XEXperia Arc SCurve 9300Xperia Mini ProGalaxy YTop ratedGalaxy S2iPhone 4SLumia 800HTC Desire HDHTC SensationGalaxy AceiPhone 4Incredible SHTC WildfireGalaxy EuropaXperia MiniHTC Desire SHTC Wildfire SCompare tariffs
Search all dealsContractPAYGDeals & offersGalaxy S2iPhone 4SLumia 800Galaxy NoteHTC SensationiPhone 4HTC Desire HDHTC Desire SGalaxy AceHTC Wildfire S

Plus

iPhone 5Mobile phone reviewsBest phonesBest Android phoneBest camera phonesBest Android phone - which should you buy?

Top 10 best Android phones compared

Find a review

MWC 2012: What to expect

A look ahead to all the latest phones and tablets

Get more from TechRadar MWC 2012: What to expectiPhone 5 rumours: what you need to knowiPad 3 rumours: what you need to knowSamsung Galaxy S3: what you need to knowPS Vita20 best mobile phones in the world todayiPhone 4SSamsung Galaxy NexusNokia Lumia 800Amazon Kindle FireSamsung Galaxy NoteNikon V1HTC RadarNikon J1HTC SensationSamsung Galaxy AceiPad 2 20 best mobile phones in the world today

Top mobile phones compared: what phone is best for you?

TechRadar Poll

Do you subscribe to a film streaming service?

YesNo, not enough contentNo, I love physical mediaNo, too expensiveWhat's film streaming?

Vote Results Best phones for music 2012

Which are the top music phones around for sound?

Where am I?Technology NewsTech newsApple newsMobile phone newsTablet newsTV newsCamera newsPC component newsPC newsLaptop newsInternet newsGadget newsGaming newsHome cinema newsHi-fi newsTechnology ReviewsDigital camera reviewsCamcorder reviewsMobile phone reviewsMP3 and iPod reviewsNetworking reviewsPC reviewsPC component reviewsLaptop reviewsTablet reviewsTV reviewsBlu-ray reviewsHi-fi reviewsTechRadarAbout usContact usSitemapReport this pageAccessibilityMedia enquiriesTerms and conditionsPrivacy policyAdvertising enquiriesJobsMore from TechRadarRegister & email newsletterFacebookTwitterYouTubeRSS feedsForumsPhone dealsSell your old mobileTechRadar Network3D RadarTap! magazineMacFormat magazinePC Format magazinePC Plus magazineLinux Format magazine

Copyright 2006 - 2011 Future Publishing Limited,
30 Monmouth Street, Bath, BA1 2BW, United Kingdom
England and Wales company registration number 2008885

Digital FutureBikeRadarT3MusicRadarGamesRadarPhotoRadar